Why does Google show how-to results for a “what is” query sometimes?
- Published November 6, 2026
- Linked from 1 answer
- In a cluster of 77
Because Google is matching what searchers want, not the grammar of their question, and for some “what is” searches the people asking want to know how to do the thing as much as what it is. Someone searching “what is intermittent fasting” may want a definition, but may equally want to know how to start. Google describes its ranking as first establishing what you are looking for, and it says it draws on how people interact with results, pooled across users, to judge whether results are relevant; how exactly that shapes a given results page is not something Google publishes.
What the results are telling you
| Results for a "what is" search | What it suggests about the searchers |
|---|---|
| Short definitions and glossary entries | They want the meaning, and that is enough |
| Definitions followed by "how it works" sections | They want meaning plus understanding |
| How-to guides and step-by-step pages | A large part of them want to do the thing |
| A mix of definitions and how-to pages | The search carries both needs |
The wording “what is” is how people open a question, and it does not settle what answer will satisfy them. The results page shows the answer Google has found works.
What to write for such a search
Answer the literal question first, in a sentence or two, then give the reader what the results show they want next: the steps, the conditions, or the first decision. A page that defines the term and stops loses to one that defines it and then shows how to apply it, when the results reward the second kind. A page that buries the definition under a long tutorial can lose the readers who only wanted the meaning, so keep the definition at the top.
Recheck over time
The balance between meaning and method can shift as a topic becomes more popular or more practical. If a definition page that used to rank starts losing to how-to pages, the search has moved; respond with what to do when a keyword’s intent changes over time. Let the results, not the question’s first two words, decide what the page delivers.
Add a comment